Special of the Month
simple-logo-Final
The Gobbler $10.00

This grilled cheese features Muenster cheese, turkey, stuffing, and house made cranberry sauce on sourdough bread. Just in time for thanksgiving!

Kids Menu
--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Kids Grilled Cheese $4.75

White bread with melted American Cheese. (Available without the crust.)

mac n cheese good 1
Kids Mac N’ Cheese $3.95
--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Crispy Chicken Tenders & Fries $6.25
--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Grilled Cheese Sticks $5.95

Our Traditional grilled cheese cut into kid size strips. Add Tomato soup for dipping!

cropped-WITH-ADDRESS-AJS.png
Mozzarella sticks $4.50

Italian style breaded mozzarella sticks with a side of marinara dipping sauce. 5 sticks per order.

Beverages
--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Fountain Drinks – 16 oz $2.25

• Coke • Diet Coke • Sprite • Iced Tea • Root Beer • Dr. Pepper •

--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Fountain Drinks – 24 oz $2.50

• Coke • Diet Coke • Sprite • Iced Tea • Root Beer • Dr. Pepper •

--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Floats – 24 oz $5.95

• Root Beer • Dr. Pepper •

--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Bottled Beverages
simple-logo-Final
Handspun Milkshakes $6.00

Choice of Vanilla bean, Chocolate, or Strawberry ice cream (Can also add in Oreo crumbles for an extra $.50)

Coffee & Espresso
--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Coffee – Regular $2.00
Grilled Cheese
traditional
Traditional $5.95

American cheese melted between two slices of sourdough.

The Southern grilled cheese with pulled pork smotherd in bbq sauce and melted cheddar on sour dough at AJ's Gourmet Grilled Cheese in Bay Shore, March, 18, 2016.
The Southern – Pork $9.75

A fan favorite this grilled cheese features our slow cooked pulled pork smothered in BBQ sauce with melted cheddar cheese between two slices of sourdough bread

bbq grilled
Buffalo or BBQ Style Chicken $8.95

Our crispy chicken smothered in BBQ or Buffalo sauce with melted mozzarella, American, or pepper jack cheese between two slices of sourdough.

simple-logo-Final
The Veggie Melt $7.95

Sautéed broccoli, onions, red and green peppers all between two slices of whole wheat or sourdough with melted pepper jack.

simple-logo-Final
Mac n’ Cheese Melt $7.95

For the real cheese lovers! This grilled cheese features our homemade Mac with extra cheddar melted on top, all between two slices of sourdough.

simple-logo-Final
The Philly Melt $9.75

Thinly sliced steak sautéed with peppers and onions, topped with melted cheddar between two slices of sourdough.

simple-logo-Final
Apple Bacon $8.75

Sliced/Sauteed apples, bacon, and melted cheddar between two slices of sourdough.

simple-logo-Final
The Hawaiian $8.95

Grilled honey maple ham, and grilled pineapple with melted cheddar between two slices of sourdough.

simple-logo-Final
The Crispy Jalapeno $7.50

Our homemade potato chips, sliced jalapeños, and pepper jack melted between two slices of sourdough.

simple-logo-Final
The Big T $8.50

Sliced honey maple turkey with melted cheddar cheese between two slices of sourdough.

--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
The Southern – Chicken $8.95

Our own pulled chicken smothered in BBQ sauce with melted cheddar between two slices of sourdough.

--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Lobster Seafood Grilled Cheese $9.95

A blend of lobster, crab, and seafood with melted cheddar between two slices of sourdough.

simple-logo-Final
The hot tot $8.75

American cheese, bacon, and tater tots all melted between two slices of sourdough bread

simple-logo-Final
The chicken parm melt $8.95

Crispy chicken, melted mozzarella cheese, and creamy tomato sauce all between two slices of sourdough bread

simple-logo-Final
The Chicken bacon bomber melt $9.99

Crispy chicken, Bacon, Homemade chip dip ( a very mild chipotle ranch sauce) and Cheddar cheese all melted between Sourdough bread

simple-logo-Final
The Gobbler $10.00

This grilled cheese features Muenster cheese, turkey, stuffing, and house made cranberry sauce on sourdough bread. Just in time for thanksgiving!

half sandwich
Half grilled cheese with soup or salad $6.00

Our first half sandwich deal! This features half of a “Traditional” grilled cheese with choice of bread, cheese and the option to add bacon or tomato along side your choice of a soup or a small side salad. Can choose from any of our on menu soups as well as any of our salads. Pricing will vary depending upon choices.

cropped-WITH-ADDRESS-AJS.png
AJ’s burger melt $7.50

Our seasoned 5oz. burger patty with AJ’s sauce, Lettuce, Tomato, red onion and American cheese!! all on sourdough bread

Soups
soups
Soup – cup $3.75
soups
Soup- Bowl $5.75
--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Grilled Cheese Sticks $5.95

Perfect for Dipping!

--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Ask about today’s soup specials!
half sandwich
Half grilled cheese with soup or salad $6.00

Our first half sandwich deal! This features half of a “Traditional” grilled cheese with choice of bread, cheese and the option to add bacon or tomato along side your choice of a soup or a small side salad. Can choose from any of our on menu soups as well as any of our salads. Pricing will vary depending upon choices.

Salads
The Grilled Cheese Salad, a traditional house salad with chopped romaine, cheddar cheese, red onion, tomatoes and shaved carrots, all topped with small slices of grilled cheese crouton bites at AJ's Gourmet Grilled Cheese in Bay Shore, March, 18, 2016.
A.J.’s Grilled Cheese Salad $7.75

Traditional house salad with a twist! Chopped romaine tossed with shredded cheddar, red onion, tomatoes, and shaved carrots topped off with our very own grilled cheese crouton bites.

walnut cran salad
Walnut & Cranberry Salad $8.45

Mixed greens, caramelized walnuts, feta cheese, and dried cranberries served with raspberry vinaigrette.

simple-logo-Final
Caesar Salad $7.95

Romaine lettuce, shredded Parmesan cheese, and crispy croutons with a creamy Caesar dressing

Dressings

Ranch, Italian, Caesar, Balsamic and Raspberry Vinaigrette.

half sandwich
Half grilled cheese with soup or salad $6.00

Our first half sandwich deal! This features half of a “Traditional” grilled cheese with choice of bread, cheese and the option to add bacon or tomato along side your choice of a soup or a small side salad. Can choose from any of our on menu soups as well as any of our salads. Pricing will vary depending upon choices.

--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Cobb salad $10.00

Romaine lettuce, crispy chicken, red onion, hard boiled egg, and crispy bacon bits served with AJ’s homemade chipotle dressing.

--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Crispy buffalo chicken salad $9.50

Romaine lettuce, grilled or crispy buffalo chicken, shredded carrots, blue cheese crumbles and sliced red onion served with ranch dressing.

--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Grilled chicken & Pineapple salad $7.25

Mixed greens, grilled chicken, and grilled pineapple served with ranch dressing.

Mac n' Cheese
mac n cheese good 1
AJ’s Mac N’ Cheese Sm: $3.95 | Lg: $6.95

Our homemade Mac is available as a side, on our grilled cheese, or as a meal!

Add Your Toppings
Pulled BBQ Pork Sm: +$2.50 | Lg: +$3.50
Bacon Sm: +$1.00 | Lg: +$2.00
Thin Sliced Sautéed Steak Sm: +$2.25 | Lg: +$3.25
Crispy Chicken Sm: +$1.75 | Lg: +$2.75
Crispy BBQ Chicken Sm: +$1.95 | Lg: +$2.95
Crispy Buffalo Chicken Sm: +$1.95 | Lg: +$2.95
Chopped Jalapeños Sm: +$0.50| Lg: +$1.00
Grilled Ham Sm: +$1.25 | Lg: +$2.25
Lobster Seafood Sm: +$2.00 | Lg: +$3.50
IMG_7134
Western Mac n cheese $6.00 / $9.00

Our famous homemade mac n cheese topped with our crispy bbq chicken, diced jalapenos and a drizzle of ranch dressing!! Comes in a small mac size or meal mac size.

Truffle oil
Dessert
simple-logo-Final
Upside Down Oreo Cheesecake $4.75
simple-logo-Final
Brioche Ice Cream Sandwich $4.50

Warm pressed brioche bun filled with your choice of vanilla, strawberry, or chocolate ice cream, topped with strawberry, chocolate, or caramel syrup.

simple-logo-Final
Oreo Churro Sticks $3.00
--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Upside Down Original Cheesecake $4.75
--WITH-ADDRESS---AJS
Original Churro Sticks $2.65
simple-logo-Final
Handspun Milkshakes $6.00

Choice of Vanilla bean, Chocolate, or Strawberry ice cream (Can also add in Oreo crumbles for an extra $.50)

IMG_7036
Baked S’mores dessert $4.00

This dessert is a graham cracker pouch stuffed with chocolate and marshmallow and then baked! It comes with 2 per order.

Sides
simple-logo-Final
A.J.’s Homemade Potato Chips With Dipping Sauce $2.25
simple-logo-Final
Tater Tots With Homemade Dipping Sauce $3.75
simple-logo-Final
Sweet Potato Tots With Homemade Sweet Dipping Sauce $4.00
french fries
French Fries $2.95
simple-logo-Final
Sweet Potato Fries $3.95
simple-logo-Final
Dill Pickle $0.50
simple-logo-Final
Corn Dog Nuggets $4.95
simple-logo-Final
Fresh Coleslaw $1.75
fried-pickles
Fried pickles $4.99

Pickles sliced into chips and coated in a batter then deep fried to a perfect crisp and served with our homemade dipping sauce

cropped-WITH-ADDRESS-AJS.png
Mozzarella sticks $4.50

Italian style breaded mozzarella sticks with a side of marinara dipping sauce. 5 sticks per order.